The Finest Eyeliners for Older Girls of 2024, Examined

Methodology: Gel pencil | Shades: 14 | Cruelty-Free: Certain

This gel pencil liner from MAC checks all the proper packing containers. It glides gently onto mature eyelids with no skipping, delivering a precise line and spectacular shade payoff that’s good for creating daring liner appears. The formulation is on the market in 14 shade decisions, from mushy brown to shiny teal, nevertheless our tester well-known she did should layer it on to realize full vibrancy and opacity, so take a more-is-more technique with this one. It’s moreover a water resistant formulation, so that you presumably can settle down understanding your liner will maintain put for as a lot as 24 hours with no smudges. Merely don’t rub your eyes, or our tester says it could start to fade.

Karla, exams: “I actually like the colorful shade payoff and the thin tip that allows for precise strains, whether or not or not skinny or daring.”

Methodology: Pencil | Shades: 6 | Cruelty-Free: Certain

Followers of conventional eyeliner pencils will love this choice from Jones Freeway, which lives as a lot because the promise of its determine. Impressed by the dense formulation of Seventies pencils, it glides on correctly and is buildable for a robust shade payoff. Our tester favored how versatile this liner is, noting that it’s capable of creating “crisp, graphic shapes” along with smoky eye outcomes—significantly when layered over a shadow. The liner is on the market in six shades, along with monochromatic shimmer decisions for further dramatic or ingenious appears.

Ashley, tester: “My favorite attribute of this eyeliner pencil is how mushy it is upon utility, which makes it easier to make use of in between the eyelashes for a tightline look.”

Methodology: Liquid | Shades: 1 | Cruelty-Free: Certain

Getting a precise line turns into more durable when the pores and pores and skin in your eyelids is far much less company than it was. That’s when a fine-tipped liquid liner like this one comes into play. It applies merely with out skipping or tugging, and it’s possible you’ll choose how thick and darkish the formulation appears—apply light pressure for sharp, incredible strains or add further pressure for a thicker, bolder look. Our tester appreciated that the liner stays moist and “workable” for some time, making it easier to restore errors or assemble as a lot as your required depth. As quickly because it’s dry, the mannequin says the waterproof formulation ought to remain smudge-proof and long-lasting, nevertheless our tester did experience some swap on a really scorching day.

Taylore, tester (not pictured): “This pen created precise strains and went on simple with out skipping or tugging.”

Methodology: Gel pencil | Shades: 7 | Cruelty-Free: No

The consistency of the Lancôme Drama Liqui-Pencil is Simple, creamy, and “luxurious” in accordance with our tester—good for mature eyes. It glides on fantastically, creating precise strains with no tugging by any means. Our tester moreover appreciated how easy it was to combine—you presumably may even diffuse it to create an eyeshadow affect if desired. She found the first swipe barely refined for her tastes nevertheless created a further dramatic affect by layering the formulation. The longevity of this liner was spectacular, too—it lasted all day with out smudging, and she or he expert merely the tiniest amount of fading.

Karla, testing: “This eyeliner feels luxurious, and the making use of is simple. It glides on, and I actually admire that.”

Methodology: Gel pencil | Shades: 5 | Cruelty-Free: Certain

Pat McGrath Labs is known for its ingenious aptitude and richly pigmented formulations, and the mannequin’s PermaGel eye pencil isn’t any exception. This liner is on the market in 5 conventional colors, along with black, brown, and blue—in enticing matte or shimmer finishes—and has an unparalleled shade payoff. Our tester favored how vibrant the liner was from the first swipe. She moreover appreciated the sleek and seamless utility course of; the creamy formulation makes creating skinny and thick strains a breeze. The liner has a shocking creamy texture, nevertheless that comes with a draw again—don’t press too onerous, or the tip could snap, and be careful for smudging when rubbing your eyes.

Karla, exams: “The pigmentation of the PermaGel Eyeliner Pencil is spectacular. The color is vibrant and true to the marketed shade. You need about one to 2 swipes for full pigmentation.”

Methodology: Pencil | Shades: 19 | Cruelty-Free: Certain

Everytime you’ve put effort into perfecting an eyeliner, you want it to stay pristine all day, and with this waterproof formulation from Victoria Beckham, it really will. Our tester was amazed by its endurance—humidity, sweat, and even eye-rubbing had been no match for this formulation. It’s out there in 19 distinctive shades, along with shimmer and glitter liner decisions that lend themselves to ingenious appears, and the sponge-tip end lets you combine and diffuse effortlessly. In accordance with our tester, the creamy texture makes the making use of actually really feel like “gliding silk all through your pores and pores and skin.” Using this liner is an costly experience from start to finish.

Karla, exams: “I wore it to an out of doors event, and it stayed put all day. The color remained vibrant with out smudging, even once I unintentionally rubbed my eyes. It’s genuinely spectacular how properly it holds up in the direction of humidity and sweat.”